Monthly Archives: February 2017

February 19 2017 – “Top bishop’s diocese under fire over child sex abuse ‘cover-up'” – Mail on Sunday – Simon Walters [Political Editor]

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4238802/Diocese-fire-child-sex-abuse-cover-up.html

Top bishop’s diocese is under fire over a child sex abuse ‘cover-up’ after a trainee vicar raped two Christian girls

  • Timothy Storey was jailed for 15 years for for grooming girls on Facebook
  • ‘Arrogant’ Reverend Hugh Valentine refused to give evidence in court 
  • Reverend Jeremy Crossley is also now facing disciplinary action
  • Richard Chartres, head of the London Diocese was urged to punished them but did not

One of Britain’s best-known bishops faced controversy last night after it emerged his diocese refused to punish two leading priests in a new church child sex abuse row.

The London diocese, headed by the Bishop of London Richard Chartres – the third most senior Church of England cleric – faced a call by the bishop’s own independent inquiry to consider punishing two priests criticised after a trainee vicar raped two Christian girls.

But the diocese did not take any action, saying it could cause further upset to the victims.

The London diocese, headed by the Bishop of London Richard Chartres (pictured) – the third most senior Church of England cleric – faced a call by the bishop’s own independent inquiry to consider punishing two priests criticised after a trainee vicar raped two Christian girls

The London diocese, headed by the Bishop of London Richard Chartres (pictured) – the third most senior Church of England cleric – faced a call by the bishop’s own independent inquiry to consider punishing two priests criticised after a trainee vicar raped two Christian girls

Oxford-educated Timothy Storey was jailed for 15 years last April after a court heard how he groomed hundreds of children on Facebook, using his position as children’s pastor to prey on ‘weak, insecure girls’.

Judge Philip Katz lambasted the ‘utterly incompetent failure’ of ‘arrogant’ church leaders to protect young girls – and accused them of a cover-up. Bishop Chartres apologised and set up an independent inquiry into the scandal.

The Mail on Sunday has established that it was concluded five months ago.

Oxford-educated Timothy Storey was jailed for 15 years last April after a court heard how he groomed hundreds of children on Facebook

Oxford-educated Timothy Storey was jailed for 15 years last April after a court heard how he groomed hundreds of children on Facebook

Its full contents were kept secret, but this newspaper can reveal the inquiry said both clerics should face disciplinary action – even though both had already been removed from their children’s supervisory roles.

We can also disclose that the two clerics – identified in the report only as ‘clergy person A and B’ – are the Reverend Hugh Valentine and the Reverend Jeremy Crossley.

Valentine was Bishop Chartres’s adviser on child protection during Storey’s reign of terror. The Storey trial judge criticised his ‘arrogance’ in refusing to give evidence.

Valentine has carried on as curate at St James’s Church, Westminster. In his sermon last Sunday, entitled Sexuality And Bishops, he accused the Church of treating gays and lesbians like ‘embarrassing relations’ and said religion had helped breed ‘hatred’, including ‘homophobia, misogyny and racism’.

Valentine also works for a young person’s charity, the Walcot Foundation. Crossley was Bishop Chartres’s director of ordinands, and is Rector at St Margaret Lothbury Church in the City of London.

During Storey’s trial, Judge Katz said the diocese was ‘stone deaf’ to complaints from the victims of self-confessed sex addict Storey, and ‘shamefully’ tried to shift the blame to police. Some of its leaders ‘seemed to be worried about the reputational damage to the diocese’.

Police praised the media for finally bringing Storey to justice.

Hugh Valentine
Jeremy Crossley

We can also disclose that the two clerics – identified in the report only as ‘clergy person A and B’ – are the Reverend Hugh Valentine (left) and the Reverend Jeremy Crossley (right)

The review ordered by Bishop Chartres said the Church should ‘consider an investigation under the Clergy Disciplinary Measure’ (CDM) into Valentine and Crossley.

It said the Church must face ‘the consequences’ of its blunders.

A spokesman for the diocese said: ‘Legal analysis concluded there were not sufficient grounds to pursue complaints under the CDM and any failed process would cause further pain to survivors.’

The decision followed an assessment by the diocesian safeguarding team, not the bishop.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4238802/Diocese-fire-child-sex-abuse-cover-up.html#ixzz4ZdlW7O5W
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

November 2014 – Operation Midland launched by Metropolitan Police [and closed in March 2016]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elm_Guest_House_claims_and_controversy#Operation_Midland_and_homicide_allegations

Elm Guest House claims and controversy

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Elm Guest House was alleged to have been used by a Westminster paedophile ring.[5] Prominent people who were claimed, without any proof, to have attended parties at Elm Guest House included the Liberal MP Sir Cyril Smith, the Conservative MP Sir Nicholas Fairbairn,[6] the Soviet spy Anthony Blunt, the former British diplomat Sir Peter Hayman, and the Foreign Office barrister Colin Peters, who was later jailed in 1989 for being part of a network which abused over a hundred boys.[4][7][8] According to The Independent, other alleged visitors to the guesthouse include a Sinn Féin politician, a Labour MP and several Conservative politicians.[3][9] During 2014 and 2015, allegations against several other leading politicians of the period, mostly now deceased, were made public in the British press.

An investigation, Operation Fairbank, led by the Metropolitan Police Service, started in late 2012. This was a “scoping exercise” aimed at a “preliminary assessment of the evidence rather than a formal inquiry”,[10] and the existence of the “assessment” operation was confirmed only on 12 December 2012 after operating in secret for several weeks.[10] As a result of allegations arising from Operation Fairbank, a full criminal investigation, Operation Fernbridge, was launched in February 2013.[11] In November 2014, another operation—Operation Midland—was set up to examine claims of a possible homicide,[12] later extended to cover allegations of three murders and activities at the Dolphin Square development in Pimlico and elsewhere;[13] on 21 March 2016, the Metropolitan Police confirmed that Operation Midland had been closed without any charges being brought.[14] In 2015, the Independent Police Complaints Commission began investigating claims that the Metropolitan Police had suppressed evidence of child sexual abuse and prevented the investigation of some allegations between 1970 and 2005, because of the alleged involvement of police officers and MPs.[15]

In addition to eight guest rooms, facilities at the three-storey Elm Guest House included a sauna, solarium and video studio.[7][16] The Edwardian house is now a private residence, and the current occupants are not connected to the allegations.[17]

Claims by Tom Watson MP

Operation Fairbank was set up following claims by Labour MP Tom Watson in the House of Commons that the police should look afresh at claims of a “powerful paedophile network linked to Parliament and No 10”.[10] Watson raised the issue at Prime Minister’s Questions on 24 October 2012.[10][18] The information was passed to him by a journalist from the investigative news website Exaro.[19] He suggested that such a network may have existed in the past at a high level, protected by connections to Parliament and involving a close aide to a former Prime Minister; neither the aide nor the former Prime Minister were named.[20]

Watson referred to Peter Righton, a former consultant to the National Children’s Bureau, who was convicted of importing and possessing illegal pornographic material in 1992. Watson said that files on Righton contained “clear intelligence of a widespread paedophile ring…One of its members boasts of a link to a senior aide of a former Prime Minister, who says he could smuggle indecent images of children from abroad.”[10]

Operation Fairbank

The police investigation known as Operation Fairbank was first set up under conditions of secrecy. The Independent on Sunday[21] reported that it focused on claims of sexual abuse and the grooming of children, involving parties for men at the former Elm Guest House in Rocks Lane, close to Barnes Common in south-west London, during the late 1970s and 1980s.

The guest house was managed at the time by Carole Kasir, who died in 1990 at the age of 47; an inquest found that the cause of Kasir’s death was an overdose of insulin. Two employees from the National Association for Young People in Care told the coroner they believed that because Kasir seemingly had not had an insulin injection for three days, she had been murdered. Nevertheless, she was found to have committed suicide.[21] A party was raided by the police in 1982, following which 12 boys gave evidence that they had been abused by men at the house. Kasir was convicted of the charge of running a disorderly house, but allegations of abuse against children, and a subsequent reported investigation in 2003, were apparently not pursued.[21]

The Independent on Sunday reported in January 2013 that police were investigating claims that Cyril Smith, a former Liberal MP who died in 2010, sexually abused young boys at Elm Guest House, which the article claimed “was allegedly used by a powerful paedophile network whose members are said to have included former leading Conservative politicians.”[22] Smith is reported to have been a regular visitor to Elm Guest House.[23] A Metropolitan Police spokesman said: “We can confirm Cyril Smith visited the premises.”[24]

In February 2013, it was reported that police were investigating allegations that in the early 1980s a “paedophile ring of VIPs” abused boys from the Grafton Close Children’s Home in Richmond, south-west London. A claim was also made that Kasir had photographs or video of many establishment figures at Elm Guest House, one photograph allegedly showing a former cabinet minister in a sauna with a naked boy.[25] One alleged victim of abuse at the guest house said that at the age of 13 he and his 12-year-old brother, both orphans, were sent there for parties when they were residents at Grafton Close Children’s home. He said boys were plied with alcohol before being abused by men at the guesthouse.[4] In March 2013, The Independent on Sunday reported that at least three men named in documents as visitors to the Elm Guest House were later convicted of multiple sexual offences against children.[7]

It was reported in December 2013 that a former Conservative cabinet minister was being investigated as part of Operation Fairbank, following the seizure of footage and photographs from a London party where children were abused in the 1980s. The film and images were seized at the home of a known paedophile in London. The unnamed politician was photographed entering the property where the party was held. One alleged victim has claimed that the ex-cabinet minister was one of those who raped him.[26] Cyril Smith and Jimmy Savile were among other alleged visitors to the parties. Some of the parties were organised by Sidney Cooke, who was jailed in the 1980s for the rape and manslaughter of Jason Swift in east London.[26] Cooke, described by The Guardian in 1999 as “Britain’s most notorious paedophile”,[27] was part of a ring of paedophiles who picked up young boys in London, often taking them to Amsterdam to be abused. Allegations were reported in December 2013 that several Conservative MPs frequently attended sex parties in Amsterdam in order to have sex with young boys.[26]

Criminal investigation – Operation Fernbridge

A full criminal investigation, Operation Fernbridge, was launched as a result of allegations that arose from Operation Fairbank. Two men, a Catholic priest from Norwich, and a man understood to be connected to the Grafton Close children’s home in Richmond, were arrested on suspicion of sexual offences and questioned by child investigation officers from Operation Fernbridge in February 2013.[11][28] A third arrest, of a 69-year-old man, took place in July 2013.[29] A trial against Tony McSweeney, the Catholic priest, started at Southwark Crown Court in February 2015. However, John Stingemore, the man who formerly worked for Richmond Council, was found dead at his home in January 2015 whilst still awaiting trial.[30] The two men always denied the charges against them.[31]

Operation Fernbridge was supported by the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children, the Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre and Richmond Social Services.[11] In June 2013 it was reported that seven police officers were working on the case and were following more than 300 leads.[19] In July 2014, the Metropolitan Police confirmed that they had more than tripled the number of officers working on the case, announcing that 22 officers were working on the operation.[32]

In March 2015, it was reported that Operation Fernbridge had closed, but that allegations that had been made to it were still being considered as part of other ongoing investigations.[33]

Westminster paedophile dossier

In 1983, Conservative MP Geoffrey Dickens compiled a dossier, telling his family it was “explosive” and would “blow the lid” on powerful and famous child abusers. The dossier was handed over to the then Home Secretary, Leon Brittan, who acknowledged receipt in a letter and suggested the police had been informed. The dossier was subsequently lost. The Observer revealed on 5 July 2014 that the Dickens dossier was just one of 114 potentially relevant files found to be missing by officials when they did their initial search.[16] The chairman of the Home Affairs Select Committee Keith Vaz said that files had been lost “on an industrial scale”.[34] In July 2014, Prime Minister David Cameron ordered an enquiry into the missing Dickens dossier,[35] and a subsequent inquiry by Peter Wanless and Richard Whittam QC failed to find the dossier or missing files.[36]

Allegations of impropriety by police officers

The Independent on Sunday reported in 2014 that the police’s Professional Standards Directorate was examining potential criminal offences by undercover officers at the time of a police raid on Elm Guest House in June 1982. The raid took place while two officers were at the premises posing as guests. A former masseur, Lee Towsey, then aged 16 (that is, under the homosexual age of consent at the time), alleged he had sex with two undercover officers at the guest house.[37]

Operation Hedgerow

In March 2013, The Independent on Sunday reported that Colin Peters, a Foreign Office barrister, was a regular visitor to Elm Guest House, where he allegedly abused boys.[38]In 1989, Peters was jailed for being part of a network of paedophiles who abused over a hundred children. Peters’ conviction followed an investigation known as Operation Hedgerow, which recorded 650 offences against 150 boys. The Independent on Sunday described Peters as being “a key figure behind one of the UK’s most extensive paedophile rings”. He was jailed in 1989 for eight years for sexual offences, conspiracy to commit a sexual offence and conspiracy to pervert the course of justice.[38]

The paedophile ring was reported as having lured young boys into prostitution. Reports at the time of Peters’ 1989 trial said the ring “was used by highly placed civil servants and well-known public figures”, but that the police did not have “the evidence or manpower to pursue them in court”.[38] Also in 1989, The Glasgow Herald reported that the paedophile ring resembled the Mafia in its organisation and strength and included “well-placed and influential professional people linked to Westminster and Whitehall”.[8]

Through this paedophile ring, Colin Peters allegedly abused boys at Elm Guest House, one of whom was Peter Hatton-Bornshim, a Grafton Close care-home resident; Hatton-Bornshin later killed himself. One alleged Elm Guest House victim said that he was also trafficked to an Amsterdam brothel where he was allegedly abused by a prominent politician.[38]

Operation Cayacos

A spin-off inquiry, Operation Cayacos, is an investigation into historical claims of child abuse by a paedophile ring linked to Peter Righton. The investigation is being conducted by the Metropolitan Police.[39]

2014 allegations

In April 2014, Simon Danczuk MP said he was convinced there had been a “network of paedophiles” operating in the House of Commons who helped to protect Liberal MP Cyril Smith. Claims were made that a 16-year-old boy had been abused by Smith at Elm Guest House.[40] Allegations had earlier been reported in The Independent that Smith had used rent boys under the age of 16 and in local authority care at Elm Guest House.[22] After it emerged that a dossier of claims made by former MP Geoffrey Dickens had apparently disappeared, Danczuk referred to the police investigation into events at the guest house when he called for former Home Secretary Leon Brittan to clarify what he knew about allegations made in the 1980s of paedophiles operating in Westminster.[41][42] It was reported by The Guardian that events at the guest house were at “the heart” of the “long-simmering sex scandal”.[16]

Retired child protection team manager Peter McKelvie, whose claims formed part of the Operation Fernbridge investigation, said in July 2014 that more than ten current and former politicians were on a list of alleged child abusers held by police investigating claims of a Westminster paedophile ring. Several, including Cyril Smith and Peter Morrison, were no longer alive, but other alleged abusers were reportedly still active in Parliament.[43] McKelvie believes there are sufficient grounds to arrest at least one senior politician.[44] McKelvie said that evidence of a powerful paedophile ring had been covered up in 1992. He told Labour MP Tom Watson that the police had discovered letters implicating powerful individuals in a paedophile network.[45]

Also in July 2014, The Daily Telegraph reported that a senior Conservative politician being investigated as part of Operation Fernbridge had allegedly been stopped by a customs officer with child pornography in the 1980s. A border guard, who is now retired, told detectives that when he searched the MP’s car he found videotapes of children “clearly under the age of 12” taking part in sex acts. He passed the material on to his superiors, but the MP was never arrested or charged over the alleged child pornography seizure because it was reported that police were understood to have insufficient evidence to take any action against the senior Conservative politician who was also accused of abusing a young boy at Elm Guest House.[43][46] A few days later, the same newspaper reported that a statement had been given by a child in 1982 alleging that he was abused at Elm Guest House by a senior political figure. It was reported that Operation Fernbridge detectives had closely examined the case of the eight-year-old alleged victim. Detectives also interviewed a retired police officer who had been involved in the original Elm Guest House investigation and who had interviewed the alleged victim at the time. The eight-year-old boy had reportedly been rescued from Elm Guest House after allegedly suffering what was described as a “horrific sexual assault” by the “leading political figure”.[47]

During this same period, in July 2014, there were also calls for the late Conservative MP Sir Nicholas Fairbairn, a former Solicitor General for Scotland, to be posthumously investigated after being linked to child abuse allegations at Elm Guest House. It was alleged that Fairbairn, who died in 1995 aged 61, was one of a number of politicians who visited the guest house in June 1982. Photographs were allegedly taken of Fairbairn—as well as Cyril Smith—at the guest house. Fairbairn was linked to alleged abuse of boys in a sauna at Elm Guest House.[6] In 2000, the daughter of a prominent Scottish lawyer had already alleged that Fairbairn, a former legal adviser to Margaret Thatcher, was part of a paedophile ring. Pete Wishart, an SNP MP, who represents Fairbairn’s former constituency of Perth, called for the allegations to be fully examined. He said: “If there is any evidence that Sir Nicholas Fairbairn was involved in the abuse of children, it should be looked at and properly investigated.”[6]

Barry Strevens, an ex-detective chief inspector for Cheshire police and former bodyguard to Margaret Thatcher, also claimed he warned her that another of her aides, Peter Morrison, allegedly held sex parties with under-age boys. Strevens said that, despite his passing on the allegations to Thatcher, she later promoted Morrison to the position of deputy chairman of the Conservative party.[48] Morrison died in 1995 aged 51 and has since been linked to alleged sex abuse at children’s homes in north Wales[48] and the alleged rape of a 14-year-old boy at Elm Guest House.[5] Three years after Morrison died, it was first reported in 1998 that he had been arrested for molesting underage boys during his career. He received a mere police caution and was never charged with any crime during his lifetime. In 2002, former Conservative minister Edwina Currie described Morrison as a “notable pederast”.[49]

Former cabinet minister Norman Tebbit said in July 2014 that there “may well have been” a political cover-up of child sex abuse in the 1980s. Tebbit, who served in various ministerial roles under Margaret Thatcher in the 1980s, said that the culture at the time was to protect “the establishment”. He said that it was seen as “more important to protect the system than to delve too far into claims”. Tebbit stated that he felt this view was “wrong”.[34] Former Labour health minister Lord Warner said that powerful people in the 1980s targeted children’s homes that served as a “supply line” for paedophiles. He described the sexual abuse of children as a “power drive”. Warner said that insufficient action was taken to deal with child abuse in the 1980s because there was “disbelief in the public mind”.[50]

In an interview with The Guardian in November 2014, Labour MP Tom Watson said: “There is no doubt in my mind that sexual abuse by powerful figures took place.” Watson said that he was aware of the name of the senior aide of a former Prime Minister who allegedly smuggled indecent images of children from abroad, but that it would be wrong for him to name the individual.[45] Watson said: “In one particular case of one person, there have been multiple allegations from unrelated people, some more credible than others, about severe cases of abuse. And in my mind I’m pretty certain that the person has broken the law and abused kids.”[45]

Two journalists—the former news editor of the Surrey Comet, Hilton Tims, and the former editor of the Bury Messenger, Don Hale—both stated in November 2014 that they had been served with D-notices, or warnings not to publish material that might damage national security, during the 1980s. Tims stated that the notice was issued directly after the newspaper began investigating rumours of activities at the guest house. Hale said that he was threatened with a D-notice after starting to investigate a file given to him by Barbara Castle, which contained details of a Home Office investigation into Geoffrey Dickens’ allegations of a paedophile ring. According to Hale, the threat of a D-notice was given by police who came into his office the day after he had received a visit from Cyril Smith, whom Hale described as “aggressive”.[51]

The Scottish Sunday Express published a claim in November 2014 that in 1985 a Scottish solicitor and former vice-chairman of the Scottish National Party, Willie MacRae, had evidence about paedophiles in the Scottish and English establishments. On 5 April 1985, MacRae’s car crashed on a remote stretch of the A87 road in Inverness-shire; he was shot in the head with a revolver and left to die. The evidence was supposedly in a briefcase in McRae’s car at the time but disappeared.[52] The gun was recovered some distance from the car, but there were no fingerprints. In 2006, a former policeman, Iain Fraser, who worked as a private investigator after leaving the police, said he was asked by a mystery client to spy on McRae three weeks before he died. Fraser added to calls for a public inquiry into the death. Repeated requests for an official inquiry into MacRae’s death have been turned down.[53]

In December 2014, an alleged “survivor of VIP abuse parties” said that he and other children were taken for weekend trips to Pimlico in the early 1980s. He said that he was abused growing up in care in north Wales and was taken to central London aged 11 or 12, where he was raped. He has been interviewed by police officers investigating the claims. The alleged victim said that children were plied with alcohol, taken into bedrooms and forced into sexual acts with various older men including MPs and government ministers. He said that other survivors have since died or in some cases have taken their own lives. The survivor of the alleged abuse said that he did not have faith in the Home Office or the Government to protect the victims.[54]

Labour MP John Mann gave Scotland Yard detectives evidence in December 2014 relating to 22 political figures suspected of involvement in Westminster paedophile rings, including three serving MPs and three members of the House of Lords. The list of those alleged to have been involved in child sex abuse included fourteen Conservative politicians, five Labour politicians and three from other parties. Thirteen former ministers were among the list, of whom at least two were alleged to have assaulted young boys at “abuse parties” held at the Dolphin Square apartment block in central London. Mann said that some of his sources were highly placed officials within institutions, and that he believed the complexity of child abuse networks at the heart of government in the 1970s and 1980s had been seriously underestimated.[55][56][57]

2015 allegations

In January 2015, an academic researcher found in The National Archives a reference to a file regarding allegations of “unnatural” sexual behaviour taking place at Westminster that probably went to the Prime Minister in the early 1980s. The file was entitled “Allegations against former public [missing word] of unnatural sexual proclivities; security aspects 1980 Oct 27 – 1981 Mar 20.” The file remains classified as it contained information from the security services and Law Officers. The Cabinet Office stated that any pertinent files would be made available to the forthcoming Independent Panel Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse.[58]

After the former Home Secretary Leon Brittan died in January 2015, he was accused of “multiple child rape”. Labour MP Tom Watson said he had spoken to two people who claimed they were abused by Brittan, including a man who alleged he had been attacked more than a dozen times as a boy. The alleged victim also said he had seen Brittan assault others. Watson said that he—along with others, including media organisations—had known of the accusations but had decided not to speak out of fear of prejudicing any jury trial that Brittan might have one day faced. Watson said he believed the alleged victims he had spoken to were “sincere”.[59]

The Independent on Sunday reported allegations that Leon Brittan had abused a pre-pubescent boy at Elm Guest House in 1982. The boy had been taken to a safe venue by police after being abused by several people, one of whom was allegedly Brittan. In 1990, Chris Fay, a campaigner for the National Association of Young People in Care, claimed on oath that Brittan had been involved in abuse and that in March 1990 he had seen a photograph of Brittan in a French maid’s uniform, with a young boy. The picture had been shown to him by Carole Kasir, co-owner of the Elm Guest House, who died weeks later.[60]

Allegations were reported that Brittan had been photographed attending a male prostitution orgy in 1986. It was alleged that young boys were picked up at Kings Cross, London and dropped off at a north London building to be repeatedly raped, but the day before the planned arrests of Brittan and other high-profile figures including the Liberal MP Cyril Smith the 1986 investigation was disbanded without explanation.[61]

Meanwhile, in March 2015, BBC’s Newsnight reported that a 1981 undercover police operation which gathered evidence of child abuse by Cyril Smith and other public figures was scrapped shortly after Smith was arrested. A former police officer, who is familiar with the original investigation and its closure, told Newsnight that Smith was arrested during an investigation into alleged sex parties with teenage boys in south London. During the three-month inquiry in 1981, officers reportedly gathered a substantial amount of evidence of men abusing boys. The order to scrap the inquiry came from a senior officer after Smith and others had been arrested. Police officers were then ordered to hand over all their evidence—including notebooks and video footage—and were warned to keep quiet about the investigation or face prosecution under the Official Secrets Act. Labour MP Simon Danczuk said: “It is my view that Smith was being protected by some fairly powerful people. They ensured that he was never put before the courts.”[62]

Also in March 2015, it was reported by The Sunday Times that police were looking into new allegations of child abuse committed by the former Speaker of the House of Commons George Thomas and Labour MP Leo Abse. The new allegations have been passed to officers leading an investigation into an alleged “network of politicians”. Earlier in 2014, South Wales Police confirmed that officers were investigating allegations that Thomas abused a boy aged 9.[63]

During this same month The Independent also published a report saying Enoch Powell was one of the MPs whose activities had been investigated as part of Operation Fernbridge. Powell’s name had been passed to police by Paul Butler, the Bishop of Durham, after allegations of Powell’s involvement in abuse were made by one individual in the 1980s to the then Bishop of Monmouth, Dominic Walker.[33] Powell’s biographer, Simon Heffer, criticised the Church of England‘s actions in “putting this smear into the public domain”, while the church stated that it had simply responded to an inquiry from the press and confirmed that allegations about Powell, which related to an alleged satanic cult rather than any criminal activity, had been passed to the police.[64] David Aaronovitch of The Times wrote in April 2015 that the 1980s claims about Powell originated from fabricated claims invented by a conman, Derry Mainwaring Knight, whose false assertions had become known to the clergy, but had been unwittingly conveyed to the police in good faith. The police found no evidence to support the allegation against Powell.[65]

Later, in an edition of Panorama broadcast on 6 October, a former Elm Guest House prostitute was interviewed who claimed that he was unaware of any MPs visiting the brothel. Journalist John Oakes told them he had investigated Chris Fay’s claims, but had never been able to find any “solid” information nor trace of photos Fay said he had seen. Fay told Panorama that 17 or 18 children from Grafton Close had told him they had been trafficked to Elm Guest House; one of them, Mark, stated that he had been an abuse victim at Grafton Close but had never been to Elm Guest House nor spoken to Fay.[66]

Operation Midland and homicide allegations

In November 2014 the Metropolitan Police announced that they were establishing a related investigation, Operation Midland, intended to examine claims made in November 2014 about a possible homicide over 30 years earlier.[12] The police later stated that three alleged homicides were being investigated as part of the inquiry, and appealed for further information regarding activities at the Dolphin Square apartment block in Pimlico near the Houses of Parliament in the 1970s and 1980s. Events elsewhere in London and at military establishments were also under investigation.[13]

“Nick”

Operation Midland arose from claims by “Nick”, a man aged in his 40s who was a child at the time of the alleged incidents.[67] Having written of his abuse, Nick was contacted by Exaro, an investigative journalism website. Exaro sold stories to newspapers about the alleged incidents, and a reporter from Exaro accompanied “Nick” to meetings with police.[68]

Nick said his stepfather, a military figure, was the first to physically and sexually abuse him and that he was subsequently passed to other figures of authority during his childhood from 1975 to 1984. Nick specifically named 12 people in a group of powerful child abusers, including Harvey Proctor, the former home secretary Leon Brittan, the former prime minister Edward Heath, the former chief of defence staff Lord Bramall, the former director of the Secret Intelligence Service Maurice Oldfield, and Michael Hanley, the former Director-General of MI5.[68] Nick claimed that he was abused at a number of places including Dolphin Square, the Carlton Club, and various other places in the home counties. Nick also claimed that the group murdered three, two for sexual pleasure, and a third to intimidate the others. Proctor’s solicitors told him that Nick had alleged that he had seen Proctor repeatedly stab a 12 year old boy before strangling him to death; and that he had been raped by Proctor.[68]

The officer leading the investigation, Detective Superintendent Kenny McDonald, said in December 2014 that experienced officers had concluded that the allegations were “credible and true”.[69] McDonald was later criticised for the statement, and it was retracted. The very public nature of the investigation was modelled on the successful investigations of Operation Yewtree, but no further witnesses came forward.[68]

Proctor detailed Nick’s claims in public for the first time at a press conference, and also named his fellow accused. In September 2015 the Metropolitan Police said that they should never have said that Nick’s claims were true. Proctor and Bramall were subsequently interviewed under caution but never arrested, and nothing was found in any police searches to support Nick’s allegations. Bramall and Proctor both wanted Nick investigated for wasting police time. Brittan subsequently died during the inquiry without knowing that police had concluded that there was no credible case against him four months before his death. Police had raided Brittan’s home six weeks after his death and taken computers, hard drives and papers without telling his widow the reason.[68]

The Labour politician Tom Watson met Nick during the early stages of the investigation and subsequently claimed that Brittan was “close to evil”. Watson later apologised to Brittan’s widow for the comment. The Conservative politician Zac Goldsmith alleged in a parliamentary speech that Brittan was an abuser. The Guardian wrote in March 2016 that “Both politicans have been accused of abusing their positions to influence the police inquiries and cast aspersions upon alleged abusers”.[68]

In December 2014, the brother of a 15-year-old who went missing in the late 1970s claimed that the teenager was among the victims abused by members of the alleged historic Westminster paedophile ring. Kevin Allen told ITV News he was “convinced” there had been “a massive cover-up” in relation to the disappearance of his brother Martin Allen from London in 1979.[70]

“David”

An episode of the BBC investigation series Panorama, The VIP Paedophile Ring: What’s the Truth? interviewed “David” and examined his claims, and found that he had “told the Metropolitan Police he was worried that two well-known campaigners may have led him into making false claims”. He said that the names were “a joke suggestion to start with but that suggestion became reality” and that he subsequently felt “guilty” for naming people he had never met and that he believed that it was “…time that the truth came out. I believe it’s time that maybe the police could stop putting their efforts into things that probably aren’t even true.” In a statement issued before the broadcast of the programme the Metropolitan Police said that they were “…worried that this programme and other recent reporting will deter victims and witnesses from coming forward in future. Seeing an individual make allegations and then be targeted by the media is not going to encourage others to speak out”.[71][72]

Disappearance and murder of Vishal Mehrotra

Vishambar Mehrotra, the father of eight-year-old Vishal Mehrotra who disappeared in July 1981 said in November 2014 that he believed his son may have died at the hands of a paedophile ring involving high-profile individuals, and that he feared that the Metropolitan Police covered up links between his son’s death and activities at Elm Guest House. Mehrotra went missing in Putney, close to the Elm Guest House in Barnes. The upper half of his torso was subsequently found seven months later, buried in woodland in West Sussex.[71] In May 1983 the inquiry into Mehrotra’s death was wound up by the police.[73] Mehrotra’s murder was linked at the time by detectives to the activities of Sidney Cooke. Police investigated the paedophile ring involving Cooke in a major inquiry known as Operation Orchid, after they received intelligence that the ring could have abducted and killed up to 20 children. Mehrotra said he was contacted by a man a few months after his son’s disappearance who suggested the boy’s abduction might be connected to the activities of a group of “powerful, high-profile” paedophiles who frequented Elm Guest House. He said that he taped the phone call and passed it onto detectives investigating his son’s abduction, but the information was never followed up.[71] Mehrotra said that “It is clear to me that there has been a huge cover up. There is no doubt in my mind.”[73]

Police also investigated a possible link between former Conservative MP Peter Morrison and Mehrotra’s death after a 46-year-old man alleged that Morrison raped him in Elm Guest House when he was aged 14, and claimed that the police covered it up. The man said he was walking in the village of Harting in 1982 when Morrison gave him some money and later lured him to London. Mehrotra’s remains had been found a few months earlier less than two miles away from Harting.[5] In March 2015, it was reported that the Independent Police Complaints Commission would investigate allegations of negligence and corruption in relation to Mehrotra’s murder.[74] Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg subsequently said that allegations that the police helped “cover up” the death of Vishal Mehrotra at the hands of a paedophile ring were “grotesque” and called for an investigation to be launched into the claims, saying that “We are in the early stages of a reckoning with our past of things happening on a scale and of a gravity which just a few months ago would have seemed unimaginable and almost too horrific to contemplate. The task is to peel back the layers of deception that appear to have happened in the past.”[73][75] The chief executive of the child-abuse charity NAPAC, Peter Saunders, said that a full-scale investigation needed to be launched into the allegations. Saunders said: “It seems beyond doubt that dreadful things, including murder have been perpetrated and that much has been covered up.”[73]

End of investigation; apologies to Bramall and Proctor’s comments

In August 2015, it was reported by The Guardian that claims against former Prime Minister Edward Heath were being investigated as part of Operation Midland.[76]

In March 2015 Metropolitan Police officers searched the homes of Field Marshal Lord Bramall in Yorkshire and London and the home of former Conservative MP Harvey Proctor on the estate of Belvoir Castle, in Leicestershire, as part of Operation Midland.[77] In interviews with the BBC, Proctor denied being part of any “rent-boy ring” or attending sex parties with prominent figures.[78] Bramall also said that “categorically, never have I had a connection or anything to do with the matters being investigated. It is not in my character or my psyche.”[79]

In January 2016 the police confirmed that there was insufficient evidence to bring any charges against Bramall and that he would face no further action.[80] The Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, Bernard Hogan-Howe later personally apologised to Bramall and said that “Although police knew from very early on they had no case to answer they couldn’t stop investigating because they didn’t want to be accused of not investigating it properly” and that the situation surrounding the inquiry arouse out of “…apparent mistakes back in 2012 relating to revelations of very serious and serial child abuse, a mixture of public outrage and propaganda” which “put immense pressure through the home secretary, on the police”. Bramall believed that a “witch-hunt culture [arose] in which child abuse, particularly historic child abuse, came to be dealt with entirely differently to other criminal offences”.[81]

Proctor was told he would face no further action in March 2016.[82] Proctor subsequently said that the investigations had “irreparably ruined my life” and that as a result of the allegations he had lost his house and his job. Proctor said “I do believe it is profoundly un-British and unfair. …I believe I have been pilloried and the Met Police service has enabled me to be wrongly depicted as a paedophile, child abuser, child murderer” and that these were the “worst things that can be said of a human being”. Proctor called on Hogan-Howe to resign and stated that Operation Midland “…has had a disastrous affect on genuine complaints of child sexual abuse, both present and historical. I think it has been incredibly counterproductive. …And when they established the truth – some time ago I think – they were too afraid of each other and the media to pull the plug.”[83]

Independent investigation into Metropolitan Police

It was announced on 16 March 2015 that the Independent Police Complaints Commission was investigating claims that the Metropolitan Police had suppressed evidence of child sexual abuse and prevented the investigation of some allegations between 1970 and 2005, because of the alleged involvement of police officers and MPs. The police referred themselves to the IPCC, which described the claims as being of “high-level corruption of the most serious nature”. The allegations included claims that an investigation into activities at the Dolphin Square flats had been halted; that no action had been taken in relation to a document from the Houses of Parliament that had linked prominent individuals to a paedophile ring; and that allegations of serious child sex abuse by a prominent politician had been covered up. The Metropolitan Police said in a statement that the allegations had emerged when officers were working on Operation Fairbank, and that they had “voluntarily referred the 16 separate allegations to the IPCC.”[15] The investigations headed by the IPCC have drawn in units from the MPS under the umbrella of Operation Winter Keys in order to support the ongoing and extensive IPCC led investigations. Evidential statements have been taken from complainants with others to follow.

See also

References

  1. Jump up^ Syal, Rajeev (14 October 2015). “Zac Goldsmith urged to withdraw paedophile ring allegations”. The Guardian. London.
  2. Jump up^ Mendick, Robert (26 September 2015). “‘VIP child abuse ring’ accuser served time in prison for fraud”. The Daily Telegraph. London.
  3. ^ Jump up to:a b Milmo, Cahal; Peachy, Paul (9 June 2013). “Police reveal scale of Elm Guest House investigation into alleged paedophile ring”. The Independent. London. Retrieved 25 August 2014.
  4. ^ Jump up to:a b c Davenport, Justin; Harper, Tom (6 February 2013). “Two arrested in paedophile probe linked to politicians”. London Evening Standard. Retrieved 26 October 2013.
  5. ^ Jump up to:a b c Gardner, Bill (5 January 2015). “Murder link to Margaret Thatcher aide accused of raping teenage boy”. The Daily Telegraph. London.
  6. ^ Jump up to:a b c “Sir Nicholas Fairbairn in child abuse scandal link”. The Scotsman. Edinburgh. 13 July 2014. Retrieved 16 August 2014.
  7. ^ Jump up to:a b c Hickman, Martin (3 March 2013). “Police failings put dozens of children at risk from notorious paedophile ring”. The Independent on Sunday. London. Retrieved 4 March 2013.
  8. ^ Jump up to:a b “Four men found guilty in ‘rent boy’ conspiracy case”. The Glasgow Herald. 3 February 1989. Retrieved 18 November 2014.
  9. Jump up^ “Tory MP warned of powerful paedophile ring 30 years ago”. The Independent. London. 22 February 2013. Retrieved 27 October 2013.
  10. ^ Jump up to:a b c d e Hickman, Martin (12 December 2012). “Scotland Yard investigating allegations senior politicians abused children in the 1980s and used ‘connections’ to escape justice”. The Independent. London.
  11. ^ Jump up to:a b c Hickman, Martin (6 February 2013). “Two arrested over claims that MPs took part in child-sex ring”. The Independent. London. Retrieved 6 February 2013.
  12. ^ Jump up to:a b “‘Possible homicide’ examined in historical abuse inquiry”. BBC News. 14 November 2014. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  13. ^ Jump up to:a b “Child abuse inquiry: Police investigate three alleged murders”. BBC News. 18 December 2014. Retrieved 18 December 2014.
  14. Jump up^ Laville, Sandra; Syal, Rajeev (21 March 2016). “Operation Midland: inquiry into alleged VIP paedophile ring collapses”. The Guardian. London. Retrieved 22 March 2016.
  15. ^ Jump up to:a b “Metropolitan Police probed over child abuse ‘cover-up’ claims”. BBC News. 16 March 2015. Retrieved 16 March 2015.
  16. ^ Jump up to:a b c Boffey, Daniel (5 July 2014). “Edwardian house at heart of a long-simmering sex scandal”. The Observer. London. Retrieved 6 July 2014.
  17. Jump up^ “Met investigates guesthouse child abuse claims”. BBC News. 18 January 2013. Retrieved 25 July 2014.
  18. Jump up^ Tom Watson, West Bromwich East (24 October 2012). “Daily Hansard: House of Commons”. Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). House of Commons. col. 923.
  19. ^ Jump up to:a b “Operation Fernbridge: Met looking into 300 lines of inquiry”. BBC News. London. 10 June 2013. Retrieved 10 June 2013.
  20. Jump up^ Hickman, Martin (25 October 2012). “Was there a paedophile ring in No 10? MP Tom Watson demands probe”. The Independent. London. Retrieved 12 December 2012.
  21. ^ Jump up to:a b c Hanning, James; Cahalan, Paul (16 December 2012). “Special report: Police revisit the grim mystery of Elm Guest House”. The Independent on Sunday. London. Retrieved 16 December 2012.
  22. ^ Jump up to:a b Hanning, James; Cahalan, Paul (27 January 2013). “Cyril Smith named in Barnes abuse case”. The Independent on Sunday. London. Retrieved 21 March 2013.
  23. Jump up^ Hanning, James; Cahalan, Paul (21 July 2013). “Elm Guest House investigation: Former senior cabinet minister faces rape investigation”. The Independent on Sunday. London. Retrieved 25 October 2013.
  24. Jump up^ “Sir Cyril Smith ‘visited alleged sex abuse guest house'”. BBC News. 13 September 2013.
  25. Jump up^ Wright, Stephen; Pendlebury, Richard (2 February 2013). “Timebomb at Elm Guest House: Pop stars, a bishop and a top politician appear on a list seized by police investigating child abuse at the London hotel in the 1980s”. Daily Mail. London. Retrieved 20 March 2013.
  26. ^ Jump up to:a b c Piggott, Mark (8 December 2013). “Ex-Tory Minister to be Questioned About Paedophile Party Claims”. International Business Times. Retrieved 18 December 2014.
  27. Jump up^ Kelso, Paul (6 October 1999). “Cooke admits years of child abuse”. The Guardian. London. Retrieved 18 December 2014.
  28. Jump up^ “Operation Fernbridge: Norfolk priest Tony McSweeney arrested”. BBC News. 7 February 2013.
  29. Jump up^ Davies, Margaret (9 July 2013). “Third arrest in Elm Guest House investigation into alleged paedophile ring”. The Independent. London.
  30. Jump up^ “Children’s home boss facing historical sex abuse charges found dead”. The Daily Telegraph. London. 16 January 2015.
  31. Jump up^ CPS to reinstate key charges after error over Elm Guest House, “Exaro News”, 6 August 2014
  32. Jump up^ Ship, Chris (10 July 2014). “Police triple number of officers working on Westminster ‘child sex abuse cover-up’ claims”. ITV News.
  33. ^ Jump up to:a b Milmo, Cahal (30 March 2015). “Tory MP Enoch Powell investigated as alleged member of Westminster paedophile network”. The Independent.
  34. ^ Jump up to:a b “Child abuse ‘may well have been’ covered up – Norman Tebbit”. BBC News. 6 July 2014. Retrieved 17 January 2015.
  35. Jump up^ Syal, Rajeev (4 July 2014). “David Cameron asks top civil servant to look into Westminster child abuse claims”. The Guardian. London.
  36. Jump up^ “‘No cover-up found’ in abuse review by Peter Wanless”. BBC News. 11 November 2014. Retrieved 11 November 2014.
  37. Jump up^ Hanning, James (13 July 2014). “Child abuse victims to sue Government”. The Independent on Sunday. London. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
  38. ^ Jump up to:a b c d Cahalan, Paul; Hanning, James (3 March 2013). “Paedophile ring leader, Colin Peters, linked to Barnes scandal”. The Independent on Sunday. London. Retrieved 18 November 2014.
  39. Jump up^ “Child abuse investigations”. BBC News. 10 November 2014. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
  40. Jump up^ Swinford, Steven (18 April 2014). “‘Influential’ politician visited guest house at centre of child sex investigation”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 8 July 2014.
  41. Jump up^ Whitehead, Tom (6 July 2014). “Westminster paedophile ring allegations: timeline”. The Sunday Telegraph. London. Retrieved 6 July 2014.
  42. Jump up^ “Leon Brittan urged to comment on 1980s ‘paedophile dossier'”. BBC News. 1 July 2014.
  43. ^ Jump up to:a b Rayner, Gordon; Barrett, David (4 July 2014). “‘More than 10’ politicians on list held by police investigating Westminster ‘paedophile ring'”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 8 July 2014.
  44. Jump up^ Smith, Lewis (4 July 2014). “Child abuse list includes 10 MPs and peers”. The Independent. London. Retrieved 3 November 2014.
  45. ^ Jump up to:a b c Aitkenhead, Decca (28 November 2014). “Tom Watson interview: ‘There is no doubt in my mind that at least one politician abused kids'”. The Guardian. London. Retrieved 7 December 2014.
  46. Jump up^ Rayner, Gordon; Tate, Tim; Hope, Christopher (4 July 2014). “Tory MP allegedly found with child porn in 1980s faced no charges, police told”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 8 July 2014.
  47. Jump up^ Barrett, David; Tate, Tim; Hope, Christopher (6 July 2014). “Westminster paedophile ring allegations: Scotland Yard detectives trace ‘victim'”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 1 August 2014.
  48. ^ Jump up to:a b Eleftheriou-Smith, Loulla-Mae (27 July 2014). “Thatcher ‘was warned of Tory child sex party claims'”. The Independent on Sunday. London. Retrieved 5 January 2015.
  49. Jump up^ Gardner, Bill (5 January 2015). “Thatcher confidant raped boy and police covered crime up”. The Daily Telegraph. London.
  50. Jump up^ Watt, Nicholas; Wintour, Patrick (8 July 2014). “Children’s homes were ‘supply line’ for paedophiles, says ex-minister”. The Guardian. London. Retrieved 19 January 2015.
  51. Jump up^ Boffey, Daniel (21 December 2014). “Media ‘gagged over bid to report MP child sex cases'”. The Observer. London.
  52. Jump up^ Murray, Paula (30 November 2014). “SNP activist ‘killed over child sex files'”. Scottish Sunday Express. Glasgow. Retrieved 24 January 2015.
  53. Jump up^ “New evidence emerges in 20-year riddle surrounding SNP man’s death”. Scotland on Sunday. Edinburgh. 10 July 2006. Retrieved 8 February 2015.
  54. Jump up^ Parmenter, Tom (18 December 2014). “Victim Shows Sky Where ‘MPs’ Abused Him”. Sky News. Retrieved 14 January 2015.
  55. Jump up^ Harper, Tom (21 December 2014). “Paedophile dossier given to Yard names MPs and peers”. The Sunday Times. London. (subscription required)
  56. Jump up^ Barrett, David (21 December 2014). “‘Paedophile’ dossier naming MPs and peers handed to police”. The Daily Telegraph. London.
  57. Jump up^ Barrett, David (23 December 2014). “Paedophile MPs focus of Scotland Yard probe”. The New Zealand Herald. Auckland.
  58. Jump up^ Swinford, Steven (21 January 2015). “Secret government file on ‘unnatural’ sexual behaviour at Westminster unearthed”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 21 January 2015.
  59. Jump up^ Millmo, Cahal (25 January 2015). “Leon Brittan sex abuse allegations: Two come forward to claim they were abused by former Home Secretary”. The Independent on Sunday. London.
  60. Jump up^ Hanning, James (25 January 2015). “Lord Brittan: The accusations against the former Home Secretary that refused to die”. The Independent on Sunday. London. Retrieved 8 February 2015.
  61. Jump up^ Magnay, Jacquelin (31 January 2015). “A missing boy and the Australian high commission in London”. The Australian. Sydney. Retrieved 8 February 2015.
  62. Jump up^ Hopkins, Nick; Morris, Jake (17 March 2015). “Cyril Smith child abuse inquiry ‘scrapped after his arrest'”. BBC News.
  63. Jump up^ “Police investigate abuse claims against late Labour MPs”. BBC News. 22 March 2015. Retrieved 23 March 2015.
  64. Jump up^ Gledhill, Ruth 30 March 2015). “Enoch Powell ‘satanic cult’ claims: CofE defends decision to pass name to police”. Christian Today. Retrieved 31 March 2015.
  65. Jump up^ Aaronovitch, David (2 April 2015). “Let’s expose the satanic abuse con artists”. The Times. London. Retrieved 8 October 2015. (subscription required)
  66. Jump up^ Panorama – The VIP Paedophile Ring: What’s the Truth? (6 October 2015) – 14:49 to 20:38; iPlayer link
  67. Jump up^ Evans, Martin (15 November 2014). “Tory MP ‘murdered’ boy at orgy, abuse victim claims”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 15 November 2014.
  68. ^ Jump up to:a b c d e f Syal, Rajeev; Laville, Sandra (21 March 2016). “Operation Midland: how the Met lost its way”. The Guardian. London. Retrieved 16 October 2016.
  69. Jump up^ Evans, Martin (18 December 2014). “‘I witnessed Tory MP strangle child’, claims abuse victim”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 2 January 2015.
  70. Jump up^ “Man believes ‘VIP sex ring’ abducted his missing brother”. ITV News. 18 December 2014. Retrieved 2 January 2014.
  71. ^ Jump up to:a b c Halliday, Josh (7 October 2015). “Panorama report: sex abuse claim against Leon Brittan ‘began as joke'”. The Guardian. London. Retrieved 16 October 2016. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name “Laville1” defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
  72. Jump up^ http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b06h7jbl BBC One Panorama – The VIP Paedophile Ring: What’s the Truth?
  73. ^ Jump up to:a b c d Smith, Amelia (19 November 2014). “Deputy Prime Minister Calls for Investigation Into Westminster Paedophile Ring Murder Claims”. Newsweek. New York. Retrieved 18 December 2014.
  74. Jump up^ “IPCC Looking At Investigation Of Boy’s Murder”. LBC News. 3 March 2015.
  75. Jump up^ Gardner, Bill (19 November 2014). “Nick Clegg: ‘Claims Scotland Yard covered up boy’s murder are grotesque'”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 25 January 2015.
  76. Jump up^ “Edward Heath: Met has been investigating claims for several months”. The Guardian. London. 4 August 2015.
  77. Jump up^ Barrett, David (8 March 2015). “Police search home of Lord Bramall as part of paedophile sex abuse inquiry”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 8 March 2015.
  78. Jump up^ “Ex-Conservative MP Harvey Proctor’s home searched by police”. BBC News. 5 March 2015. Retrieved 6 March 2015.
  79. Jump up^ Symonds, Tom (9 March 2015). “Ex-army chief Lord Bramall ‘mystified’ by police search of house”. BBC News. Retrieved 9 March 2015.
  80. Jump up^ Rawlinson, Kevin (15 January 2016). “Lord Bramall ‘will face no further action’ in Operation Midland investigation”. The Guardian. Retrieved 16 January 2016.
  81. Jump up^ “Lord Bramall ‘receives Met Police apology’ over abuse claims”. BBC News. 15 January 2016. Retrieved 14 October 2016.
  82. Jump up^ Evans, Martin (21 March 2016). “Operation Midland: Harvey Proctor told he faces no further action”. The Daily Telegraph. London. Retrieved 21 March 2016.
  83. Jump up^ “Operation Midland: Harvey Proctor criticises child abuse inquiry”. BBC News. 29 March 2016. Retrieved 21 March 2016.

August 2015 – Operation Conifer – Wiltshire Police – Sir Edward Heath

http://www.wiltshire.police.uk/news/3117-statement-in-relation-to-the-sir-edward-heath-investigation-following-the-henriques-review

Statement in relation to the Sir Edward Heath investigation following the Henriques Review

Posted in News

“The Henriques review was commissioned to look in to the Metropolitan Police’s handling of Operation Midland and other investigations concerning persons of public prominence within the Metropolitan Police area. Accordingly the review was not focused on Operation Conifer.

“Wiltshire Police is the national lead in relation to Operation Conifer. The purpose of Operation Conifer is to investigate allegations of child abuse made against the former Prime Minister Sir Edward (Ted) Heath. In addition, the investigation aims to safeguard children and vulnerable adults who may be at risk of abuse today and, where relevant, bring living offenders to justice.

“The operation commenced in August 2015, following an IPCC press release naming Sir Edward Heath as a suspect in an investigation into non-recent child sex abuse.

“Operation Conifer is investigating a number of separate allegations made by persons who have come forward. Two arrests have taken place in relation to Operation Conifer and, at this time, both remain on police bail. Due to the fact that this remains a live investigation it would not be appropriate for us to comment any further at this stage.

“A panel of independent experts outside of policing are providing ongoing scrutiny of the investigation to ensure its proportionality and justification. Furthermore, in line with recognised best practice, Wiltshire Police recently commissioned Operation Hydrant to undertake an independent review of the investigation to ensure its ongoing proportionality and justification.

“Further to the release of the Henriques review Wiltshire Police, in conjunction with the College of Policing and the National Police Chiefs Council, will consider where relevant any national guidance and policy recommendations that may impact upon the ongoing Operation Conifer investigation.”

November 25 2016 – “Bishop George Bell case: ‘A perfect storm from which injustice emerges'” – The Justice Gap – Jon Robins

http://thejusticegap.com/2016/11/bishop-george-bell-case-perfect-storm-injustice-injustice-emerges/

THE JUSTICE GAP

‘A perfect storm from which injustice emerges’

george-bell-2A leading barrister has been appointed to conduct an independent review into how the Church of England handled allegations of child abuse made against one of its most revered bishops after claims that he was the victim of a ‘grave miscarriage of justice’.

Lord Carlile of Berriew will look into allegations made against the late Bishop George Bell, described by the historian Ian Kershaw as ‘the most significant English clergyman of the 20th century’. As well as being Bishop of Chichester for close to 30 years, Bell was a supporter of the German resistance, a friend to the German pastor Dietrich Bonhoeffer who plotted to assassinate Hitler and an outspoken critic of the Allies’ carpet bombing of German cities such as Dresden. His reputation was until October last year regarded as ‘close to saintly’ but now it is left in tatters.

Some 37 years after Bell’s death a woman known as ‘Carol’ made complaints that he had abused her when she was a young girl in the late 1940 and early 1950s. The allegations first arose in 1995. Last October a claim was settled by the Church of England and compensation reported to be £15,000 was paid out. The current Bishop of Chichester Dr Martin Warner issued a formal apology. ‘I am committed to ensuring that the past is handled with honesty and transparency,’ he said.

Supporters of the late Bishop claim that the investigation was anything but transparent. In July this year two members of the General Synod, Martin Sewell and David Lamming, both retired lawyers, proposed a motion of ‘no confidence’ in the investigation.

Speaking to the Justice Gap, Martin Sewell says: ‘The Bell case is almost unique in having been placed in complete purdah. You can’t get anything out of the Church and that is what raised our hackles. It must deal with these matters with transparency and accountability.’ Shortly after the motion of ‘no confidence’, which so far has 40 out of the necessary 100 signatures, the independent review was announced and this week it was confirmed that Lord Carlile would head it up.

‘My job is neither to damage nor salvage anybody’s reputation,’ the Liberal Democrat peer said this week. ‘My job is to report on the way in which the Church of England looked into these issues and people will be able to draw their conclusions from the review that I produce.’


george-bellA perfect storm
Martin Sewell spent 30 years as a lawyer specializing in child protection. ‘The Bell case represents the perfect storm from which injustice emerges,’ he says. ‘We had a Church fearful and sensitive to allegations that it might be covering up abuse, a plausible complainant, a long dead Bishop with no living heirs, and a culture which had abandoned the presumption of innocence in favour of asserting that all complainants are entitled to be believed. When you add that the whole process was veiled in secrecy it is no surprising that those who treasured Bishop Bell’s memory and those who assert the importance of due process for all should combine to insist upon a truly independent review.’

As reported in the Justice Gap in a debate in July, Lord Carey, the former Archbishop of Canterbury, spoke of his ‘distress’ at the Church’s treatment of the case and claimed that its procedures ‘had the character of a kangaroo court and not a just, compassionate and balanced investigation of the facts’.

The George Bell Group was set up in response to the perceived unfairness at the late Bishop’s treatment. The campaign – supported by former chairman of the Bar Desmond Browne QC, historian Andrew Chandler, Frank Field MP and the Conservative Peer and historian Lord Lexden – calls the wording of the October statement ‘(at best) reprehensibly equivocal, and (at worst) positively misleading’. As a result of that statement it was widely and incorrectly reported that Bell was a proven paedophile. Critics claim that the church’s conduct of the case have fallen considerably short of even a civil standard of proof (i.e., balance of probabilities).

In his statement Bishop Warner insisted that ‘the scrutiny of the allegation has been thorough, objective and undertaken by people who command the respect of all parties’. The George Bell Group point out that the Bishop did not identify the ‘parties’ to whom he was referring and ‘provided no information about the scrutineers, their number, their professional backgrounds or (most important of all) the nature of the process they undertook’. This last point was ‘especially relevant’ since the statement did not suggest that any corroboration of the allegations had been found, the group added. They also point out that the inquiry team did not have a lawyer to assist them on the assessment of their evidence.

Supporters of George Bell highlight a number of striking omissions from the Church’s investigation. Most notably, it failed to interview Canon Adrian Carey, Bell’s chaplain at the time of the allegations who is still alive. ‘He was virtually the bishop’s butler and would have been with him at all times,’ explains Martin Sewell. ‘When there was a knock on the door, it would be Adrian Carey who would answer.’ Canon Carey has said it would have been impossible to imagine how abuse could have taken place. The George Bell Group points out there appears to have been no attempt to access Bell’s papers and diaries. Dr Andrew Chandler, Bell’s biographer, has said that Bishop’ daily life was ‘meticulously documented by himself and almost constantly observed by those who lived and worked with him. Bell shared almost all his time with his wife, secretary, domestic chaplain and driver.’

In an article that appeared in the Church of England Newspaper last October (The Rule of the Lynch Mob) spoke of the ‘discontent with the Church of England’s behaviour over the way it has handled abuse allegations against one of its greatest sons’. It talked of the ‘hysteria and a lynch-mob mentality’ surrounding some cases of historic abuse citing the false allegations made against politicians such as Ted Heath, Leon Brittan and Harvey Proctor. ‘The Church is now as much a part of this overreaction as any other part of society,’ it said.

You can download the George Bell Group review here

Profile photo of Jon RobinsAbout Jon Robins
Jon is editor of the Justice Gap. He is a freelance journalist. Jon’s books include The First Miscarriage of Justice (Waterside Press, 2014), The Justice Gap (LAG, 2009) and People Power (Daily Telegraph/LawPack, 2008). Jon is a journalism lecturer at Winchester University and a visiting senior fellow in access to justice at the University of Lincoln. He is twice winner of the Bar Council’s journalism award (2015 and 2005) and is shortlisted for this year’s Criminal Justice Alliance’s journalism award

“Refugees” – A Poem by Brian Bilston

6a00e551f08003883401a5117313fa970c.png

“REFUGEES” BY BRIAN BILSTON

THEY HAVE NO NEED OF OUR HELP

SO DO NOT TELL ME

THESE HAGGARD FACES COULD BELONG TO YOU OR ME

SHOULD LIFE HAVE DEALT A DIFFERENT HAND

WE NEED TO SEE THEM FOR WHO THEY REALLY ARE

CHANCERS AND SCROUNGERS

LAYABOUTS AND LOUNGERS

WITH BOMBS UP THEIR SLEEVES

CUT-THROATS AND THIEVES

THEY ARE NOT

WELCOME HERE

WE SHOULD MAKE THEM

GO BACK TO WHERE THEY CAME FROM

THEY CANNOT

SHARE OUR FOOD

SHARE OUR HOMES

SHARE OUR COUNTRIES

INSTEAD LET US

BUILD A WALL TO KEEP THEM OUT

IT IS NOT OKAY TO SAY

THESE ARE PEOPLE JUST LIKE US

A PLACE SHOULD ONLY BELONG TO THOSE WHO ARE BORN THERE

DO NOT BE SO STUPID TO THINK THAT

THE WORLD CAN BE LOOKED AT ANOTHER WAY

 

(NOW READ FROM BOTTOM TO TOP)